close

Trading a restaurant with zero hygiene rating perfectly legal

Food hygiene ratings

A restaurant or takeaway that receives a zero hygiene rating is not automatically shut down even though many consumers think it should and such an action would appear to be “common sense”, a leading food safety expert has said.

The current food hygiene grading system operated by the Food Standard Agency runs from 0-5. However, the ratings are composed of cleanliness levels, documentation and the layout of an establishment. It is therefore not as clear cut as to whether the cutlery is clean or whether there’s a dead rat in the jam.

According to Fiona Sinclair, director of food safety at STS, it’s something that may seem like common sense to consumers, but the reality of the situation may be a little less widely understood.

Story continues below
Advertisement

She says that certain events need to happen for an establishment to close down, and that it’s not unusual for some establishments to stay open with a ‘0’.

“To close a premises an emergency prohibition notice (EPN) needs to be served by the Environment Health Organisation. Service of EPNs is governed by legislation and codes of practice, and closure is only permitted where there is an ‘imminent risk’ to public health.

“Examples include uncontrolled pest infestation, an outbreak arising from premises or even flooding with sewage. So, a food business can be poor, but if there is no ‘imminent risk’ they cannot be closed. Instead, other enforcement powers can be exercised, such as prosecution, service of improvement notices, but they won’t be shut down. A ‘0’ grading will also be subject to routine inspections at the maximum frequency of six months, potentially with revisits in between.”

Another common misconception is whether establishments get prior warning of when an EHO is visiting the premises to conduct checks.

Mrs Sinclair says that EHOs have a ‘power of entry’ and must be permitted entry at any reasonable time.

“Generally this means when anyone is present on the premises. To not allow an EHO in is an offence called obstruction, for which the business can be prosecuted. Most EHO inspections are unannounced, although some local authorities do announce their inspections to make sure the manager or owner is available to speak with.”

Currently, the law states that businesses in Wales and Northern Ireland are legally required to show their FSA rating, however firms in England do not have to display the rating they have been awarded.

Tags : food hygieneRestaurants
Andrew Seymour

The author Andrew Seymour

2 Comments

  1. How is that it in Wales restaurants have to display their food hygi4ne rating by law but in England they don’t?
    I wonder what the point is then if an establishment gets a zero rating and they are able to hide it? This is wrong as it misleads the customer into thinking the restaurant or cafe is doing ok. Myself and my friends make sure we see the hygiene rating of a place before we go in. If we can’t see it we do not go in. Either way if II saw a rating less than 3 I would not use it. Surely this is safety and choice issues for the customer for the rating to be displayed

    1. They might not have to display it in the premises, but the food safety website is searchable and displays the rating for every food premesis. So it can never fully be hidden from the public. Some food ordering apps also provide the link to that takeaways food hygiene rating page so you can click it before ordering from them

Leave a Response